After posting the FSM Expelled video, it was obvious to some (and hopefully all) that several quotes were taken out of context, and certain views were shown in a biased way.
This was all intentional! The point of the video was satire, and the target was Ben Stein and the Discovery Institute’s upcoming Expelled trailer. They take clips from leading”darwinists” and show nice long interviews from IDers. In the spirit of satire I chose to do the same, giving pro-FSMers a long speech and quote-mining the “darwinistic” supporters.
However, I choose to do one more thing to poke at Expelled - I’ve now released all the interviews to YouTube completely UNCUT! Let’s see the Discover Institute’s full interviews online (with the false premises exposed).
So here they are (in order of most to least misrepresentation):
PZ Myers has the pen for wit and sharp criticisms of the Discovery Institute. In this installment we see him drawing an analogy with those non-”Wrightists” who know that people can not fly.
From the Nova special last week on the Dover trials, it was shown that in an early draft of “Of Pandas and People” (the ID-friendly “biology” textbook from the Discovery Institute) there was a slip up in one of the edits where “cdesign proponentsists” where mentioned (as a change from “creationists” to “design proponents”). This was one of the key pieces of evidence that ID was just religious creationism relabelled.
“Evolution isn’t true because clocks never spontaneously evolve,” well if you make them alive and breed them in a computer simulation you can have clocks form from a pile of gears.
I just read an amazing article about a better way to explain or illustrate the concepts of evolution to people it may be unfamiliar to entitled “Evolution and the Wisdom of Crowds.” He uses the examples of Wikipedia, prediction markets, and the Netflix recommendation system to explain how evolution can produce things which seem intelligently designed, but don’t have to be.
Greta Christina posted a great article which pretty much sums up what one can be upset about when being atheist/agnostic/non-religious. Many of these are reasons organizations like our UofA Atheists and Agnostics have come into existance.
When it comes out in February 2008, everyone please ignore Expelled starring Ben Stein as the rebel with a cause - getting ID into science classrooms. I hope someone can teach Ben what exactly the Scientific Method is, and why ID isn’t science (instead of psuedo-conspiracy theories).